| | | to Labour Party
 | to Independent
 | to Chamber of Commerce and Ratepayers Association
 |
| from Labour Party |  | 128
(30.1%) | 211
(49.6%) | 86
(20.2%) |
| from Independent |  | 131
(18.7%) | 405
(57.8%) | 165
(23.5%) |
| from Chamber of Commerce and Ratepayers Association |  | 36
(7.3%) | 142
(29.0%) | 312
(63.7%) |